Minds of young children are highly impressionable. They are strongly
influenced by what they learn from their parents and teachers. It is only much
later that some of them make a near-complete break from the childhood
conditioning, and strike on their own. My own rejection of the unscientific and
irrational way of thinking at the age of ~17 years is an example. But most
people are not able to make this kind of a break. In particular, it is very
difficult for them to undo the brainwashing regarding religion and God etc.
Ideally, enlightened parents should strive to create
conditions in the family in which the child can grow to become an independent
thinker, unencumbered by the views his/her parents or teachers may hold.
Credulity in a child is an evolutionary necessity. It suits the child as well
as the parents. But every child has a right to be exposed to all streams
of thought before making a choice.
Imagine a scenario in which a child learns to have full
confidence in the scientific method, and therefore in science. Such a person
will not waste energy and time fighting what science has to say. Instead,
he/she will take even the counter-intuitive quantum mechanics for granted, all
the time fully conscious of the fact that there is nothing dogmatic about the
concepts and theories of science, and even the most cherished scientific ideas
can be abandoned if the new evidence so demands. Such a person will be able to
have a rational and objective view about the (failed) hypothesis about God,
even when he/she does not have the expertise to understand the advanced scientific
ideas used in, for example, Hawking's book I mentioned in the previous post.
The present
situation is pathetic and alarming. In India, in most cases even a six-month
old child gets exposed to religious mumbo jumbo. Around that age the child gets
the first solid food and, sure as ever, the event abounds in religious
('auspicious') trappings.
What right the
parents have to impose their views on a child? The child should be able to make
a choice after learning about the various streams of thought. Is that asking
for too much? Are we being fair to our children?
Needless to
say, the parents do it with good intentions. Most of them believe that a
religious upbringing will instill moral values in the child. But do they
succeed? I don't think so.
How moral is
it to kill in the name of religion?
How moral is
it to perpetuate social injustice in the name of religion?
How moral is
it to stifle the intellectual growth of a child in the name of religion (e.g.
by teaching creationism)? If you teach your child that something is true simply
because the 'holy book' says so, you are destroying something very valuable,
namely the urge to go on questioning things till a rational and sensible answer
has been obtained.
How moral is
it for parents to teach a child that their religion (or caste) is superior to
all others?
I can go on.
Now contrast
this with a situation in which a child has imbibed the spirit of the scientific
method, and has blossomed into a rational, mature person who realizes that
there is no God up there to intervene and help us in case we mess up our
affairs on this planet. That Mother Earth is our collective responsibility, for
which we should cooperate with one another, rather than waste our energy and
resources in mindless conflicts in the name of religion.
Imagine a
world in which human beings, after they grow up from childhood, are no longer
children in their emotional get-up, but are mature, responsible, and
mentally strong persons, who hold nobody but themselves accountable for all
their actions. They do not need a father figure (God) to whom to go crying for help like a child does. They are noble and moral because it feels good to be so, rather
than because they believe that God will punish them if they are not good. And
what kind of God is this which first makes people do what he wills, and then
punishes them for their actions?
By adopting a strictly logical, honest,
and objective approach to empirical observations and data, humanity has been able to
achieve so much. To appreciate this properly, and to take pride in our
scientific heritage, your child should understand the basics of this approach.
In particular, he/she must learn to admire the indomitable human spirit which,
in spite of the hostile conditions in which it had to progress, came up on top
by adopting THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD of interpreting natural phenomena.
‘Science is the process that takes us from
confusion to understanding in a manner that’s precise, predictive and reliable
– a transformation, for those lucky enough to experience it, that is empowering
and emotional’ (Brian Greene).
Do you really want to deprive your child
of this empowerment, and cripple his/her mental growth? Think about it.
Richard Dawkins has recently written a book, The Magic of Reality, which explains to children how the scientific version of reality has far more magical beauty and fascination than any of the prevailing myths about reality.It is designed to be intelligible to 12-year olds, perhaps with some help from enlightened parents. How about buying a copy of the book for your child?
Richard Dawkins has recently written a book, The Magic of Reality, which explains to children how the scientific version of reality has far more magical beauty and fascination than any of the prevailing myths about reality.It is designed to be intelligible to 12-year olds, perhaps with some help from enlightened parents. How about buying a copy of the book for your child?
With or without religion, good people can behave well and bad people
can do evil; but for good people to do evil - that takes religion [Steven Weinberg (Nobel Laureate).]
I agree totally with this approach to parenting. The problem is that so many parents never become adults, all their live they are fearful, in need of imaginary friend, just like children. Gods have been created by people as such imaginary friends in pre-scientific times. Those who stick to their "friend" beyond childhood, will never mature. Nothing good is coming from children parenting children. That is why our main duty as parents are first of all to mature, to rid off childish imaginary friends who prevent us from exploring beyond the safety zone of religious "truth".
ReplyDeleteThanks Margaret. You will enjoy reading the following article:
Deletehttp://nirmukta.com/2012/07/09/freethought-parenting-issues-joys-and-challenges-part-i/